Rate My LandlordAbout

67 West 89th Street

Manhattan · Upper West Side (Central), NY 10024

67 West 89th Street is an 8-apartment building in Upper West Side (Central), built in 1895, managed by Castagnello Realty LLC. The City has 15 open housing-code violations on file for it, one of them immediately hazardous, about 1.9 per apartment, roughly three times the neighborhood norm for a building this size (HPD, as of 5 October 2026). Tenants filed 6 complaints with 311 in the past year, which the City closed in a median of 8 days (311, as of 5 October 2026). No tenant has reviewed it here yet. Everything above comes from the City's own records.

Managed by Castagnello Realty LLC

Be the first to review this building

Does the heat hold in January? How long does the super take? No public record answers that.

Write the first review

About a minute, no account, stays anonymous.

Units
8
Year built
1895
Borough
Manhattan

This building’s record with the City

Complaints tenants filed with 311, and repairs a City inspector has asked for. Most repairs are routine maintenance. Both describe the building rather than the people in it, and often predate the current management.

1.8/5Worse than most nearbyScored from the records below against every building we cover. It is not a tenant rating. Nobody who lived here said this.

6tenant complaints

Filed with 311 in the past year

Typically closed in 8 days · neighborhood median is 4

15open repairs

Outstanding with HPD · about 1.9 per apartment

Immediately hazardous
1
Hazardous
9
Non-hazardous
5

What the open repairs are about

  • Stairs, floors and ceilings8
  • Leaks, damp or mould3
  • Smoke and CO alarms2
  • Heat or hot water1

Source: NYC 311 and Housing Preservation & Development. Look this building up · updated Oct 2026

The company that manages it, elsewhere

Castagnello Realty LLC manages 7 other buildings we cover, holding 76 apartments.

open violations
46open violations
immediately hazardous
12immediately hazardous
311 complaints
3311 complaints

in the past year

per apartment
0.6per apartment

The company’s record across its other buildings, not this building’s. A company can run one well and another badly, and these figures often predate the current management. (HPD and 311, as of 5 October 2026.)

What tenants say

Nobody has written about 67 West 89th Street yet.

Does the heat hold in January? How long does the super take? Does management answer the phone, and were you charged what you expected? No public record answers any of that. Only someone who lived here can.

Be the first to review

About a minute, no account, stays anonymous.

Also on West 89th Street

Every building on West 89th Street →

Also managed by Castagnello Realty LLC

Their whole portfolio →